Football Records
NAIA-FCS National Champion Runner-Up
1986, 2016
NAIA-FCS Semifinals Appearance
1987, 1989, 1990, 1993, 2016
NAIA-FCS Quarterfinals Appearances
1980, 1983, 1984, 1992, 2013, 2015, 2016, 2018, 2020
NAIA-FCS First Round Appearances
1988, 2008, 2012, 2013, 2015, 2016, 2017, 2018, 2019, 2020
NAIA-FCS National Playoff Appearances
1980, 1983, 1984, 1986, 1987, 1988, 1989, 1990, 1992, 1993, 2008, 2012, 2013, 2015, 2016, 2017, 2018, 2019, 2020
Conference Championships
1979, 1980, 1983, 1984, 1985, 1986, 1987, 1988, 1990, 1991, 1992, 1993, 2013, 2015, 2016, 2017, 2018, 2019, 2020
NAIA National Player of the Year
Logan Brettell - 2016
CoSIDA Academic All-American of the Year
Logan Brettell - 2016
All-Time NAIA Scholar-Athletes
Brett Wahlgren - 2005
Silas Williams - 2005, 2006
Brett Woods - 2006, 2007, 2008
Jeffrey Juiliano - 2006, 2007
Mack Brown - 2007, 2008, 2009
Clint Benge - 2008, 2009
David Foltz - 2008
Andrew Patch - 2008
Bradley Thimmesch - 2008, 2009
Brad Fawcett - 2009
Austin DeGraeve - 2009, 2010
Garrett Chumley - 2009, 2010, 2011
Matt Brock - 2009, 2010
Will Baum - 2009
Jesse Green - 2010
Caleb Johnson - 2010
Joel Murphy - 2010, 2011, 2012
William Chambers - 2010
John Babb - 2010, 2011
Jacob Morse - 2011
Reno Marical - 2011, 2012
Lucas Roepke - 2011
Jesse Schultz - 2011
Andrew Taliaferro - 2011, 2012
Sam Vossen - 2011, 2012
Dominick Reiske - 2012, 2013
Aaron Rieschick - 2012
Scott Schrag - 2012
Steven Stewart - 2012
Connor Stremel - 2012, 2013, 2014
Bryan Williams - 2012, 2013
Tanner Clark - 2013, 2014, 2015
Logan DeGraeve - 2013, 2014
Sheldon Farrell - 2013
Justin McCandless - 2013, 2014
Gunnar McKenna - 2013, 2014
Richard Schacher - 2013, 2014
Alex Baird - 2014, 2015
Jake Heller - 2014
Sheldon Jacks - 2014
Michael Lisher - 2014
Daniel Sumler - 2014, 2015
Michael Thomason - 2014, 2015
Nick Becker - 2015, 2016
Darrell Holden - 2015
Adam Lomenick - 2015, 2016
Emerson McGuire - 2015, 2016
Myron Tipton - 2015
Birdsong Warren - 2015
Sam Wescott - 2015, 2016
Jess Westmoreland - 2015
Nadir Zayyad - 2015
Logan Brettell - 2016, 2017
Jacob Tompkins - 2016, 2017, 2018
Kyle Wittman - 2016
Dalton Brinegar - 2017
Camden Wheatley - 2017
Zach Hipsher - 2017, 2018
AJ Totta - 2018, 2019, 2021
Landon Decker - 2018
Jarrett Alley - 2018
B.J. Harvey - 2019, 2020
Billy Wagemaker - 2019
Brandon Lewis - 2019
Carter Odell - 2019, 2020
Colton Hutchinson - 2019, 2020, 2021
Grant Elston - 2019, 2020
Hunter Englebrecht - 2019
Mitchell Henry - 2019, 2020, 2021, 2022
Nate Pauly - 2019, 2020, 2021
Ashkon Ghafari-Saravi - 2019, 2020, 2021
Sam Huckabee - 2019, 2020
Tanner Matthias - 2019, 2020, 2021
Zac Morgan - 2019, 2020, 2021
Calvin Ball - 2020
Brennen Feeback - 2020, 2021, 2022
Jordan Finn - 2020
Shane Skwarlo - 2020, 2021, 2022
Jayden Brown - 2022
Jeff Moore - 2022
Jess Duckworth - 2022
Nolan Gray - 2022
Sam Heggemann - 2022
Sean Urban - 2022
Thad Metcalfe - 2022
Tyler Stieffermann - 2022
CoSIDA Academic All-American Team
Logan Brettell - 2016
CoSIDA Academic All-District Team
Gunner McKenna - 2014
Tanner Clark - 2014
Michael Lisher - 2014
Nick Becker - 2016
Logan Brettell - 2016
Kyle Wittman - 2016
Landon Decker - 2018
NAIA All-Americans
Dick Shores - 1958
Ron Frazier - 1984
Terry Heads - 1984
Joe Meyer - 1984
Chuck Osborn - 1998
Mark Emry - 1999, 2000
Carlos Grace - 1999, 2000
John Reeves - 2003
Ryan Smith - 2005
Derek Doerfler - 2007
Colton Miller - 2010
Andre Jolly - 2012
Sheldon Jacks - 2014
Tucker Pauley - 2015
Clarence Clark - 2015, 2016
Logan Brettell - 2016
Josh Kock - 2016, 2017
Darrain Winston - 2016
Cornell Brown - 2016
JD Woods - 2018, 2019, 2020-21, 2021
Nate McLaurin - 2017, 2018
Jared Harvey - 2018
Landon Decker - 2018
Kegan Schumann - 2018
Mitchell Henry - 2022
Canon Karn - 2023
*ALL-TIME Series and ALL-TIME Coaching Records
Scoring
| Points/game | 40 | Kermit Lange | 1930 |
| Points/season | 186 | Cornell Brown | 2016 |
| Points/career | 669 | Clarence Clark | 2013-17 |
| Kicking points/game | 17 | Tony Butts/Ron Frazier/Clarence Clark | 1980/1984/2016 |
| Kicking points/season | 124 | Clarence Clark | 2016 |
| Kicking points/career | 389 | Clarence Clark | 2013-17 |
Total Offense
| Total yards/game | 475 | Logan Brettell | 10/22/16 |
| Total yards/season | 5,371 | Logan Brettell | 2016 |
| Total yards/career | 9,825 | Logan Brettell | 2014-17 |
Rushing
| Rushing yards/game | 313 | JD Woods | 2017 |
| Rushing yards/season | 1,775 | Kevin Alewine | 1985 |
| Rushing yards/career | 4,492 | Ed Lierz | 1985-88 |
| Rushing attempts/game | 42 | Terence Spencer | 2000 |
| Rushing attempts/season | 281 | John Reeves | 2003 |
| Rushing attempts/career | 708 | Ed Lierz | 1985-88 |
| Most 100-yard games/season | 9 | Kevin Alewine Richie Bryant |
1985 2009 |
| Most 100-yard games/career | 23 | Ed Lierz | 1985-88 |
| Most cons. 100-yard games | 12 | Kevin Alewine | 1984-1985 |
| Most 200-yard games/season | 4 | Cedric Colbert | 1997 |
| Most 200-yard games/career | 5 | JD Woods | 2017-Present |
Passing
| Passing yards/game | 433 | Mack Brown | 2008 |
| Passing yards/season | 5,073 | Logan Brettell | 2016 |
| Passing yards/career | 9,095 | Logan Brettell | 2014-17 |
| Pass attempts/game | 54 | Marco Aguinaga | 11-4-17 |
| Pass attempts/season | 582 | Logan Brettell | 2016 |
| Pass attempts/career | 1,287 | Mack Brown | 2006-09 |
| Consecutive attempts without interception | 150 | Logan Brettell | 2016 |
| Pass completions/game | 36 | Mack Brown | 2009 |
| Pass completions/season | 406 | Logan Brettell | 2016 |
| Pass completions/career | 768 | Mack Brown | 2006-09 |
| Highest pass completion percentage/season | 74.4 | Logan Brettell | 2015 |
| Consecutive completions/game | 26 | Tim Sheldon | 1993 |
Receiving
| Receiving yards/game | 221 | Gary Greenwood | 1993 |
| Receiving yards/season | 1,135 | Clarence Clark | 2017 |
| Receiving yards/career | 4,180 | Clarence Clark | 2013-17 |
| Most receptions/game | 18 | Nick Snider | 2017 |
| Most receptions/season | 95 | Cornell Brown | 2016 |
| Most receptions/career | 247 | Clarence Clark | 2013-17 |
Touchdowns
| Touchdowns/game | 6 | Kermit Lange | 1930 |
| Touchdowns/season | 31 | Cornell Brown | 2016 |
| Touchdowns/career | 51 | Ed Lierz | 1985-88 |
| Rushing touchdowns/game | 6 | Kermit Lange | 1930 |
| Rushing touchdowns/season | 25 | JD Woods | 2017 |
| Rushing touchdowns/career | 49 | Ed Lierz | 1985-88 |
| Passing touchdowns/game | 7 |
Logan Brettell |
2016 |
| Passing touchdowns/season | 52 | Logan Brettell | 2016 |
| Passing touchdowns/career | 87 | Logan Brettell | 2014-17 |
| Receiving touchdowns/game | 6 | by several players | |
| Receiving touchdowns/season | 16 | Bobby Bates/Clarence Clark | 1980/2015 |
| Receiving touchdowns/career | 44 | Clarence Clark | 2013-17 |
Kicking
| PAT made/game | 12 | Tony Butts/Clarence Clark | 1980/2016 |
| PAT made/season | 88 | Clarence Clark | 2016 |
| PAT made/career | 245 | Clarence Clark | 2013-17 |
| Consecutive PAT made | 51 | Mike Gardner | 1986-87 |
| Field goals made/game | 5 | Derek Doerfler | 2007 |
| Field goals made/season | 23 | Derek Doerfler | 2007 |
| Field goals made/career | 48 | Derek Doerfler/Clarence Clark | 2006-09/13-17 |
| Best punting average/season | 41.0 | Ryan Smith | 2005 |
Longest Plays
| Run (touchdown) | 97 | JD Woods | 2017 |
| Pass (touchdown) | 99 | Logan Brettell-Clarence Clark | 2017 |
| Punt return (touchdown) | 90 | Jack Warner | 1960 |
| Kickoff return (touchdown) | 101 | Xavier Lewis | 2010 |
| Interception return (touchdown) | 100 | C.J. Boram | 2005 |
| Field Goal | 62 | Derek Doerfler | 2007 |
| Punt | 79 | Brent Hanf | 1989 |
| Fumble return (touchdown) | 92 | Matt Brock | 2009 |
Defense
| Tackles/game | 25 | Jeremiah Gress | 2005 |
| Tackles/season | 142 | Mickey Ramsey | 2001 |
| Sacks/game | 4 |
Josh Saunders/Andrew Patch/Nick Becker/Josh Kock/Landon Decker |
1994/2009/2016/2016/2018 |
| Sacks/season | 16 | Andre Jolly | 2012 |
| Sacks/career | 33 | Andre Jolly | 2011-14 |
| Pass break-ups/game | 7 | Dax Barker | 2000 |
| Pass break-ups/season | 23 | Matt Tripplett | 2001 |
| Blocked kicks/game | 2 |
Marco Aires |
1991 2001 2005 2018 |
| Blocked kicks/season | 10 | Eric Moore | 2001 |
| Interceptions/game | 4 | Darrick Smith | 2013 |
| Interceptions/season | 11 | Tommy Cannon Robert Villafranca |
1976 1991 |
| Interceptions/career | 28 | Roger Hornbeck | 1968-71 |